Falcons Texans trade proposal

falconidaeTATF · Joined: 25 Mar 2013 Posts: 92

Mod edit: You can't post links to other forums. So I've deleted the link, but we can still keep this post to debate. -mse326

Here's a proposed trade from TATF- the Falcons messageboard, wanted to get Texan's fans opinion of it.

Julio Jones
6th pick
3rd round pick
2015 3rd round pick

for
DeAndre Hopkins
1st pick
2nd round pick

Falcons would then have pick
1st- Jadevaon Clowney DE
33rd - Morgan Mosses OT
37th - Jimmie Ward S

Why Falcons make the trade - Instead of giving up multiple draft picks to move up to 1 they give up there most valuable possession in Julio is coming off a injury . Julio has the potential to be one of the best Wrs in league but Falcons can't risk him being on the sidelines or giving up multiple picks to move up to 1 . Falcons will downgrade from Julio to Hopkins but still pick up a capable wr that can grow into a 1wr someday . They fix the trenches with Clowney and Mosses and still have a cheap young talented wr

Why the Texans make this trade
They want out 1 and want to secure a QB they desire . They also give that I coming QB a potential great wr to work with once Andre Johnson retires. They already have a play maker on defense now they have one on offense . They slide down couple spots upgrade the talent of wr and pick up a extra 3rd round pick in next years draft

Hannibal3188 · Joined: 23 Jan 2013 Posts: 257 Location: Cleveland, OH

Heck no.

1. Hopkins for Jones just makes us older at a position where we already have an aging Andre Johnson reaching his twilight years. I (and I think most on this forum would agree) saw enough from Hopkins last year to be confident in his ability to take over as WR1 when AJ retires in a couple years.

2. Us picking at number 6 and then not picking again until the 3rd round is a terrible idea for us. If we went 2-14 and the ONLY reason for that was QB, we wouldn't need to trade out of the first pick in the first place. But we have more holes than that, and Receiver wasn't one of them, so this cripples our ability to get multiple starters in this draft. We'd MAYBE get the QB we want at 6, then don't pick again until 65? No thank you.

3. I think you're either underestimating the difference between 1-1 and 1-6, or overvaluing the difference between Julio Jones and DeAndre Hopkins, or both.

That said, I do hope that Houston does trade down in this draft with either y'all or Cleveland, however I hope the deal looks almost nothing like this.

BladeKor · Joined: 26 Feb 2012 Posts: 1199

Don't listen to him.

falconidaeTATF · Joined: 25 Mar 2013 Posts: 92

Grasspike · Joined: 07 Jan 2007 Posts: 5209 Location: td's basement

Yes. The odds Nuk turns out to be as good as Julio Jones are slim and I think we could get Teddy with #6. It would be tough giving up #33, but an AJ/Julio receiving corps makes for a much easier first two years for whoever we draft at QB and gives us a true #1 for when AJ starts to fade.
_________________

Sig by matthouston91

LORK 88 · Joined: 09 Feb 2005 Posts: 6110 Location: Endor

A trade down only makes sense if we gain more picks from it. We have a good number of holes to fill so giving up a 2nd for a 3rd in a deep draft like this would be foolish. Julio Jones is set to get a monster payday soon and Hopkins is under contract for at least the next 3 years. For as good as Julio is, he's struggled making it through a full season healthy.
_________________

ADOPT-A-TEXAN: CJ "Polish Hat" Fiedorowicz

mse326 · Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2014 10:24 pm Post subject:

Not a chance.

Our 1 = your 1, 2, and 2015 1
Our 2 = your 2 and 4
Hopkins = late 1

Out of that you are only giving us your 1. So it cancels. That leaves us with this.

We should be getting
late 1, 2, 2, 4, 2015 1

We are getting
3 and 2015 3
Julio Jones

The 3 and 2015 3 is about equal to a late 2. Both the 2s we're owed are high 2's, so let's take out the picks you owe and change one of the 2's to a late 2 (late 2 plus late 2 = high 2)

Is Julio Jones worth a late 1, high 2, low 2, and a 2015 1st? Not even close.
_________________

#JDI

Wolf6151 · Joined: 10 Feb 2008 Posts: 2878 Location: Pearland, Texas

PAtexansFAN99 · Joined: 04 Jan 2007 Posts: 4508

No
_________________

Marco79 · Joined: 14 Jan 2007 Posts: 11590 Location: Bloomington, IN

That is a terrible trade.

Apollo Stallion · Joined: 06 Feb 2008 Posts: 5863 Location: Battle Red State

Awful for all the reasons outlined above. I still maintain that if we hadn't muffed 2012 so badly with Posey / Martin and aggressively targeted one of the slot receivers including Kendall Wright, TY Hilton, Ryan Broyles, Chris Givens, or at worst just settled for Rueben Randle who would have been fine as a #2 (or my preference Dwayne Allen as blocking & red zone TE) we wouldn't have had to burn last years #1 on a guy like Hopkins who clearly wasn't the best receiver on his own team and will top out as a possession #2. As for this proposal, if WR was so important to us, why wouldn't we just draft a young healthy Sammy Watkins and be done with it which would buy us 3 extra years of cost control at the position vs. putting ourselves in the position of having to cut AJ in 2015 to resign Julio? I maintain that the Falcons would have been in a Super Bowl if they hadn't mortgaged their future in thinking they were ONLY one player away and sold out to get Jones. If they could have ever figured out how to draft RBs and CBs in the draft vs. killing their cap with expensive has-beens they might have gotten over the hump. Count me amongst those who doesn't think last year was just a one year injury related blip.
_________________

12 Year Texans Season Ticket Holder

Pastor Dillon · Posted: Fri Apr 25, 2014 9:52 am Post subject:

It would have to be Atlanta 1st and 2nd plus 2015 1st or maybe we take atlantas 1st, 2nd, 4th, 6th and a mid round 2015 pick

Depends on what value we give it
_________________
2014 Adopt-A-Texan
Andre Johnson
75 catches 802 yards 2 TD
Carrer marks:
1,002 catches 13,463 yards 63 TDs

BladeKor · Joined: 26 Feb 2012 Posts: 1199

texansfan · Posted: Fri Apr 25, 2014 2:03 pm Post subject:

The loss of a 2nd round pick for us is why this is a losing proposition for me. I like the upgrade of Julio over Deandre, but as Apollo pointed out, we are essentially trading for Julio right when his next contract is about to kick in. The transition from Andre to Julio would likely be seamless, as Andre doesn't have much time left. But we are really sacrificing when we give up a valuable 2nd round pick this year.

Deandre and our first, for Julio and your first and second this year seems more realistic to me. I understand we are upgrading our receiving corps by doing this, but you are getting a receiver that is under cost control for the next few seasons, plus adding a playmaker like Jadeveon Clowney.

Pastor Dillon · Posted: Sat Apr 26, 2014 10:25 am Post subject:

Trade with the falcons and pick up an extra 2nd and a 2015 1st and then trade pick 6 to the 49ers, pick up their 2 2nds, and a 2015 1st

We suddenly have 5 picks between 29 and 60. That's 5 guys we can plug right into the roster and start or contribute and then in 2015 we have 3 1st rounders.
_________________
2014 Adopt-A-Texan
Andre Johnson
75 catches 802 yards 2 TD
Carrer marks:
1,002 catches 13,463 yards 63 TDs