What do you think about Santonio Holmes?

[Jetsqb101]

I've seen that common logic for this upcoming off-season involves cutting Santonio Holmes in order to try and bring in a new #1 target, which I understand since Holmes has had some issues and injuries recently, but I've also noticed that a lot of Jets fans seem to just not like the guy.

This is weird for me because I actually love Santonio Holmes despite all of the first down celebrations and drama he can bring. The dude has tremendous talent and he has really given it his all in his stint for the New York Jets in my opinion, embracing the fact that he would be our number one wide receiver. He could've phoned it in with us since we didn't have a strong offense, but instead he gave us an explosive(and clutch) pass catcher who our QB could rely on. A lot of his problems lay in his ego, but I'd argue that when you've made plays that Santonio has made that you've earned the right to play with that swagger and it in fact probably makes him a better player.

My opinion aside, are you glad that Santonio Holmes came to the Jets and do you like him as a player?

[CallOfKtulu]

Loved him in his first year here. Haven't really liked him since. Hopefully he can win me over when he comes back from injury.

[jg6041]

Dude is real. Reasonable contract and him wanting to stay fits perfectly.
No loss if he goes, love to see him stay.
_________________

[rickyt31]

If he was our 2/3 and shut up, I would have loved him. His attitude is so bad, people really believed he was faking his injury at the beginning of the season. Maybe if he step up and act like a #1, he can win me over.
_________________

[Raoul Duke]

When he's on the field and healthy, he changes the dynamic of the offense. He really is one of the better WR's in the game.

As far as his attitude, I'm not on the practice field or in the huddle with him so I can't comment on that. But Geno seems comfortable with him.
_________________
“You don’t burn out from going too fast. You burn out from going too slow and getting bored.”

- Cliff Burton

[Davey]

There was something VERY wrong in 2010 that we never really got to know about. It was obvious he was a big problem. Since then, it's been more a problem of staying on the field.

I'm still a firm believer in his talent, I just don't think it's going to be here.

[jg6041]

[green24]

As a person? I think he's a -.

As a receiver and overall package, I think he's not quite the receiver he was a few years ago. He's been slowed by injuries and he isn't that young anymore. When he's on, he's a legit #1, but he's "on" maybe once or twice a season. When he's playing, he's a great tool (pun intended) to have. However, I think after this season we should be looking at a #1 or starting receiver to replace Holmes. We should be looking at someone who can have the high (pun not intended, unless we draft Sammy Watkins), but not prove to be a detriment to the team at times.

There is a thread in NFL Comparisons where it asks you to rank the top 15 players on your team. Towards the tail end of the list, I listed Holmes, Kerley, and Hill consecutively. It is really hard to tell at this point who is our #1, #2, and #3 receiver. They all have very different track records, skill sets, and roles in this offense, yet you could really order them in any way you want.

[jg6041]

[green24]

[glenearl18]

He's an awesome dude. After a Lions game a few years ago all these players were gathered in a circle at midfield to pray to god and Holmes was running around them doing "the Jet". The cheeseburger incident was funny too. I'd be sad to see him go.

[jg6041]

[Malik]

Overrated estimated player his entire career who would of been the #2 on the majority of teams his entire career and a #3 on a half dozen as well. He's really not worth keeping. He is a zero intangibles type player who sometimes can make clutch catches but is usually pretty nonexistent outside of those rare moments.

[Imarobot]

[rickyt31]