Get Campbell, draft Geno Smith, keep Stanzi, seems obvious.

[Taylor916]

Bring in Jason Campbell via free agency, a relatively talented veteran. Draft Geno Smith, a future franchise QB. Keep stanzi who is still coachable and has potential. Jason Campbell is a great mentor and teacher for two young quarterbacks. He is talented enough to start until Geno out playes him. Who ever does best can play but im sure that will be Geno. Seems obvious to me. I heard Dorsey is big on taking the best player available which is stupid. Id hate to think im smarter than the nfl best but it seems obvious that Geno is worth our number 1 as bad as we need a QB. Im sorry if this is already posted as I dont read but 30% of posts and im sure many have thought of this but it seems obvious.

[RaidersAreOne]

Yes, bring in Campbell.
_________________
First jersey purchased: Jamarcus Russell.
Second jersey purchased: Rolando McClain.
Next purchases: Every Chiefs, Chargers and Broncos player.

[ryknowssd]

[KC_Guy]

[valkrei]

I want Geno smith #1 and I want him to start. As long as we can provide good protection we need our #1 to start developing imediately. Maybe we will get lucky and this guy can do well like some QB's in the most recent draft have.
_________________


Props to Loto Tailback for the SIG!

[kylecumberland]

[Taylor916]

I watched Stanzi play at Iowa several times, I live in iowa city and before that lived in nebraska who is in the big ten with Iowa. Stanzi will never be great but could be functional which is much more than Cassel. We do not need the BPA. We already have a great team on the field who cannot win due to cassel mainly but also coaching and Pioli. This team is a superbowl contender right now with a good QB. Manning would have gone much further with us than the donks but who can blame the man for snubbing Pioli and company. Our second biggest need is cornerback after QB. Dorsey is obviously a fabulous scout but to not take the best QB available would be a critical mistake. More enormous talent on top of great talent will not help with another 2nd rate QB. And raiders dude? Whats wrong with cambpell? You did much better with him than worn out old Palmer, you should have kept him.

[Victor1124]

Everybody always says BPA but every single team drafts within their needs.Green Bay always drafts for their needs but for some reason has this BPA mystic about them.

[kylecumberland]

[Bobikus]

[Taylor916]

Smith has an 80 to 90% chance of being a good starter to where these others are more like 50%. Tyler wilson and the kid from usc maybe decent starters but are injury prone. Smith has a good shot at starting sometime next year. If stanzi does not stay im cool with drafting two quarterbacks. All the talent in the world is pointless if we dont have a good qb. Jamaal charles cant win by himself and recievers need a qb.

[kylecumberland]

[Bobikus]

Every team keeps needs in mind, especially when they're drafting high and actually have glaring needs. The good teams don't draft pure BPA, they just don't take complete reaches as often.

When the Packers picked up Rodgers, Favre was already 35 years old and had already begun waffling on retirement. QB WAS a need when they picked Rodgers, and likely would have started earlier had he not been kinda raw mechanically coming out considering how Favre played in 05-06.

Pure BPA is a myth, teams ALWAYS keep their needs in mind. Just that when your team at the moment is good enough to be picking low in the round, those needs don't always mean you need a day 1 starter at a position.
_________________
Geno Smith, Tavon Austin, Stedman Bailey, and Bruce Irvin will all have at least 1 pro bowl season each by the end of the decade.

[Taylor916]

I agree with you 110% bobikus. Often just having a good qb gives you more freedom to draft BPA. I admit our 2008 draft is a big reason we have a lot of talent. Taking Eric Berry worked out fabulous as did Flowers. Drafting DL players 1st round has been a bust twice and is old. Drafting BPA has worked out very well a couple times recently and a couple times not like Glen Dorsey and that other DE. Fact is we need a QB so bad that we cannot skio on a franchise QB just because we pick 1st and the experts say Geno is worth a 15th pick. Sometimes you have to reach. If we dont, I promise you Jacksonville will and we will suck again with more studs on the team.

[Rumless]

It is such a myth that Geno is head and shoulders above these other QBs.
_________________