REDandPEWTER's 2012 Draft Grades

[REDandPEWTER]

Bucs Draft Grades:

1st Round: Mark Barron Safety Alabama (via Trade Jacksonville):

[bucsfan333]

#7 S Mark Barron A+
-At first I hated the pick. Now I realize the pick and the VERY underrated trade were the right moves. Awesome job, Dom!!

#31 RB Doug Martin A
-We leapfrogged the Gmen to grab our guy using that forth we gained from the Barron trade. Dom played it perfectly. Martin is an every down back that can block and catch the ball. Great pick.

#58 OLB Lavonte David A+
-There were mocks with him going in the second. He's the LB we all wanted. A little manipulation from Dom and we moved up and got our guy. Brilliant!

#140 ILB Najee Goode C
-He's a two down run stuffer. We needed the depth. Our rush defense has been nonexistant for a few years now so the pick makes sense.

#174 CB Keith Tandy B
-I'm surprised we waited so long to get a CB. Tandy was our guy and he fills a position of need. I like the pick.

#212 RB Michael Smith B+
-I love it! Speed speed speed. We needed it. We also needed depth at RB. Great pick.

#233 TE/FB Drake Dunsmore C
-He's a legitimate FB. We needed one. I like the pick.

Overall A
-We filled needs with GREAT players. I don't feel we reached for anyone. We didn't draft any boom or bust guys. Dom's ability to manipulate picks is pure genius. We drafted four guys that can start right away. This is better than a draft that would've had Richardson or Claiborne.
_________________

Adopt-a-Buc Mike Evans 11 RECs 169 YDs 2 TDs

[sandman2300]

would've liked to take a shot on Dennard in the 7th instead of maybe picking a fullback- thought he had some good skills in college and is certainly a good person to check out- patriots made a good pick I think

[manilathrilla1]

This Off-Season was the best that I can remember. I remember getting Simeon Rice and Brad Johnson in the same Off-Season, but this one takes that one for sure.

Getting the best Guard in the league and a top flight WR for half of what Calvin Johnson signed for is amazing. And the draft Barron, Martin, and David. WOW

[bucsfan333]

[REDandPEWTER]

We got Johnson its all good

[youngbuc20]

I love the first three moves. I also love the fact Dominik was aggressive getting his guys. Barron, Martin, and David were all solid picks and are gonna be major contributors.

I actually really like the Najee Goode pick. He reminds me somewhat of a Curtis Lofton. He is a two down thumpper who excels in run support but is a liabilty in coverage. However I think he would have been there in the 6th and I really would have loved to get Josh Norman. I hate that he is a Panther. However not complaining cause like I said I like Goode and think he is a gem.

The Tandy pick makes me curious. We waited all the way to the 6th to draft a corner. I wonder what Shiano and staff see in Biggers, Lewis, and Gaitor? I don't know alot about Tandy except that he is best in zone.

Don't know much about Dunsmore. Actually I know nothing about him. Anyone care to offer some insight?

This has deffinetly been one hell of a Buccaneer Off-season
_________________

[REDandPEWTER]

[mfw096]

I really wish we got Chris Rainey for some speed, but either way we had a solid draft and I can't complain at all now.
_________________
Adopt a Buc:
2012 - Doug Martin
2013 - Darrelle Revis

[RB4TampaBay]

WOW, what an outstanding off season. First the FA's that we signed, then the way that the Bucs performed during this draft. Some of these picks were certainly not the ones that I would have gone after, but now that it is done I am completely in agreement with who they have picked up. The first three we all know and I know that they are all starters in game one. The other four I knew nothing about, but as I research them I am finding out why they were chosen. Next, the ever increasing list of UDFA's, I'm sure that we will be learning more about them soon.

I could not be more thrilled with what we have done thus far, and where I think that we are going. Just an outstanding job by Mark and the coach's, it is going to be a most exciting spring and summer as we see things starting to improve. I would most certainly give them all an A for their efforts thus far.

[RoeKG]

[dbtb135]

1. Mark Barron: B-.

I think there's been some changes of heart a little faster than usual on the Barron pick. Mainly because people loved what we did in the two picks after that, and combined, it looks like a great first 3 picks. But I don't think Barron is worth a top 7 pick. I just don't see him as a special safety. He's good, but comparatively to safeties that have gone that high in the past, I just don't think he stacks up. Which isn't to say he's a bust, I think he'll be very solid for us. But in terms of value, I don't think he's great. And this being a forum that is always thumping on BPA, BPA, I do think it's odd how many have justified it with the talk of how big a need safety was without Tanard. Or even with Tanard, it was. And yes, he was the best safety in the class (not saying a whole lot). But as a stand-alone player, I don't think he's a top 10 pick. More of a borderline top 15. And to give up the pick that gets Jacksonville one of the truly elite players and get only a 4th hurts more. And then seeing the Cowboys have to pay a high 2nd for Claiborne.....well, let's just say I'd rather forget this early part of the draft.

1. Doug Martin: B+.

I've come around on Martin, but I still don't know about the value of it again. Martin had become the consensus #2 back in the class. But I do feel it was a weaker RB class past Richardson. Martin is a good all-around back, but I think the Rice comparisons are unwarranted. Rice was a MONSTER in college. I like Martin's chances of unseating Blount as the starter, and I think he'll be reasonably productive. There seemed to be a talent drop-off before both our picks in round 1. The last 5-6 picks in round 1 would likely resemble the mid-2nd in a better draft, but before that you had a lot of value in guys like DeCastro, Reiff, Mercilus, and Hightower. Again, the need was glaring. And again, the talent, while very solid all-around, seems to be a little light on the high upside.

2. Lavonte David: A+.

I'll admit, I wasn't HUGE on David like some as a target at the top of round 2. But even I was surprised to see him drop this low, and the value was extraordinary. Unlike our first two picks, there seemed to be value beyond the pick slot at the end of round 2 as I think a lot of teams made out. The Packers with Worthy, the Lions with Broyles, the OL picks of Konz/Adams/Osmele, and of course the unbelievable pick of Randle to the Giants. There was more talent than usual available at the end of round 2, and I'm glad that Dom was smart enough to assess this and make the move. I think we all agree that David will win the WSLB job going away in camp and solidify that weakness for years to come.....

5. Najee Goode: B-.

I'm not big on him, but I don't think he'll disappoint as the back-up at Mike. I think Carder or Kaddu might be better long-term, but it's not an awful pick. To be fair, the talent level at this point left a lot to be desired.

6. Keith Tandy: A-.

I always like CB depth later on, and Tandy has some talent. I really wish we weren't so high on defenders from WVU though, because I only saw them twice last year. Hardly enough to get a good grasp on their talent level. Either way, I came away remembering Tandy and not all that high on Goode.

7. Michael Smith: I.

As in I have no idea, because I have never seen him play. But 1,300 yards in 3 years at a small school seems a little light. I wouldn't expect much just based off that, but who knows? Do we have any Utah St fans in our fanbase who really know anything about the kid?

[He Hate Me]

^
Who would have been a better pick at 7?

[dbtb135]

[bucsfan333]