NINERS TRADE W/ CHARGERS

martisius · Joined: 28 Jan 2005 Posts: 54

The Niners trade with the chargers to get the 12th and 28th pick, at 12 they draft David Pollack or Mike Williams, then at 28 they draft Jamal Brown, then in the first pick of the second it would be Mark Clayton. Then in latter rounds they draft the sleeper lynn Mcgruder DT from OKlahoma.

mauRICE 80 · Joined: 20 Dec 2004 Posts: 772 Location: Yay Area

I like the trade down but I don't like your picks. We would still be stuck with Rat also.

martisius · Joined: 28 Jan 2005 Posts: 54

well there aren't any potential probowl qb's only recivers and running backs, on offence. t.a. MacLindon (rb) I feel if he stays healthy will be a good one.

Chrissooner49er · Joined: 03 Feb 2005 Posts: 3641 Location: Tulsa, OK

There is nothing wrong with Rattay! Tim Rattay will pick apart a defense as well as most anyone else currently in the NFL IF he has the Offensive Line to give him the time! Last year's record was a direct result of the injuries and lack of coaching for the offensive line--not the fault of Rattay or Dorsey! It would be a wasted pick to take a 1st round QB with a healthy Rattay behind a healthy and prepared O-line!

martisius · Joined: 28 Jan 2005 Posts: 54

you are right Chrissooner49er rat isn't that bad, i believe any of Qbs in the draft will only be as good as rat. thats why the niners should get jamal brown (oklahoma) and put him at left tackle and either put K.harris at right tackle or just release him. then hopefully the o-line can stay healthy and rat will do fine.

reg4422 · Joined: 04 Dec 2004 Posts: 86

Niners fans should not want this to happen. Trading for the Chargers 2 1st rounders would be a terrible trade for the niners. If they trade down they need to get a first rounder this year and NEXT year. Next year's draft will be twice as deep as this years(Bush,Leinart,Ferguson,Winston etc.). I think the ideal trade for the 9ers would be to get the Raiders 1st this year and next. I think the Raiders might make an offer because they want DJ, and don't want the Dolphins taking him at #2. The Raiders will be terrible again next year, so this would work out great for the 9ers. #7 this year and probably top 10 next year instead of 12 and 28 with a weaker draft.

martisius · Joined: 28 Jan 2005 Posts: 54

trading to next year isn't a bad idea but all of those guys Bush,Leinart,Ferguson,Winston won't be any good in the nfl. bother of those o-lineman aren't good at pass blocking and leinart is a system QB. r.bush could be the acception, he might be better as a reciver though.

reg4422 · Joined: 04 Dec 2004 Posts: 86

I agree with you about Leinart, I don't think he's that great. But, I disagree about Ferguson and Winston. And, Bush is ridiculous, I would take him over anyone coming out right now. I just named a few though - Leak, McNeil, Hawk, Brooks are some more. I just think it would be wise if the 9ers could get a 1st rounder next year instead of the 28th this year if they can pull it off.

martisius · Joined: 28 Jan 2005 Posts: 54

you make a valid point reg4422. but now you would draft r.bush over m. williams?

reg4422 · Joined: 04 Dec 2004 Posts: 86

If it was my choice, yes. I love Mike Williams, but to me Reggie Bush looks like Bryan Westbrook x3. I think he is the ultimate weapon, with him and Barlow in the backfield it would definately take pressure off of whoever the quarterback is.

danny18 · Joined: 12 Feb 2005 Posts: 48

i like the tradee..it would be a big plus if we get mike williams and maybe a qb in the second round or thrid round

martisius · Joined: 28 Jan 2005 Posts: 54

i'd get mike williams if they'd use plan X. plan X if the quick fix. its getting j. garcia, or k. warner in the freeagency then k. macardell, then a good experienced LT then mike in the first pick.

Montana168 · Joined: 14 Feb 2005 Posts: 1095

wow i hope that does not happen at all , there is no way edwards or williams will be available that late in the draft and we'll get screwed over like we did last year. i hope we do not trade out of the no 1 spot unless its for these reasons

a pick still in the top 5
or
a good player and a draft pick
or
a first rounder in next years draft

martisius · Joined: 28 Jan 2005 Posts: 54

yeah that all sounds well and good but, whatdo you think about plan X?

greatone323 · Joined: 21 Jan 2005 Posts: 32 Location: California

You have the Chargers trading up and then you getting Mike Williams as a Chargers fan if we trade up it will be for Mike Williams possibly Derrick Johnson. Convential wisdom is the Chargers trade up for the guy you say you would get at 12. Williams or Braylon Edwards would not be available at 12.