Joined: 19 Jan 2008 Posts: 16688 Location: mike23md on the sig
Posted: Sat Oct 13, 2012 11:15 pm Post subject:
Slauson deserved to be fined. IMO those knee shots are as dangerous as headshots. They should be treated with the same type of discrimination.
If they were really concerned about health, an not hot button topics, they'd adopt that QB hit box to all defenseless players.
The one that really bugs me is how ball carriers can grab a defender by the facemask and yank him to the ground, and the network will show 3 slo-mo replays. But if a defender grabs mask? Flags come out.
thats actually illegal. they cant grip the face mask. they can only put there hands on the face masks. which isnt really dangerous.... grabbing the face mask and twisting it is dangerous...hence the rule.
but was the slauson play even illegal? i get it hurt someone and should be against the rules...but is it actually against the rules?
Yes. Peel back block to the knee is illegal
EDIT: Maybe not. I read from our beat reporter who has been doing it for decades that it was a peel back but reading the rule I don't think it was becasue the rule requires the blocker me moving towards his own end line (Rule 12 Section 2 Article 4).
If there is another rule that applies I didn't see it. I also may be remembering the play wrong. I recall the blocker moving toward our end line.
Ultimately there is also the catchall unnecessary rougness that in theory has defined terms but is not limited to those terms. (The rule says "there shall be no unnecessary roughness. This shall include but is not limited to..." 12-2-6 in link above). It could be said this is unnecessary (the diving at the knee part).
thats what i was thinking. i didnt think the play itself wasnt illegal.
and the unnecessary roughness would be a slippery slop. the runningback could ahve cut back just before that and had been stopped by cushing. and going for the lower body would be necessary because he already got past him.
After seeing the gif above it was a peel back and I remembered the play wrong. He was coming back toward his own endline.
All times are GMT - 4 Hours Goto page Previous1, 2
Page 2 of 2
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum